اللحظة الي خسرنا فيها السباق: القصة الحقيقية للثورة الصناعية

هل كان تفوق الغرب حتمية تاريخية، أم مجرد سلسلة من الصدف الجغرافية والقرارات المؤسسية الحاسمة؟ في هذه الحلقة من برنامج "تاريخ وحضارة"، نغوص في أعماق اللحظة التي افترق فيها مسار الإنسانية. نعود إلى القرن الثامن عشر، حينما كانت حواضر الشرق كالقاهرة ودمشق وإسطنبول تقف على قدم المساواة مع لندن وباريس، لنطرح السؤال الأهم: لماذا انطلقت الآلة البخارية من أوروبا، بينما غرق عالمنا في ركود طويل أدى إلى فجوة حضارية نعيش آثارها حتى يومنا هذا؟ 

Follow us:-

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/tareekhwhadara/

X: https://x.com/tareekhwhadara

Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/cw/TareekhwHadara

Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@TareekhWHadara

Email: TareekhWhadara@gmail.com

المصادر:-

التباعد العظيم (The Great Divergence) – كينيث بوميرانز

ثروة وفقر الأمم (The Wealth and Poverty of Nations) – ديفيد لاندز

الثورة الصناعية في التاريخ العالمي (The Industrial Revolution in World History) – بيتر ستيرنز

لماذا تفشل الأمم (Why Nations Fail) – دارون أسيموجلو وجيمس روبنسون

التاريخ الاقتصادي والاجتماعي للدولة العثمانية – خليل إينالجيك

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Amrax Elt Haraksu Adlesh Duan Melianab Da Oropio Asioye Siaratmin Orobo Asia Sharkayi Telefonatmin America Maenul Orijanat meets anybes, Mantna canet with Sadar, Ahamil Moerit, Mansuja to Melabes usaat, Yani Lawa Fnab Elfusaba Miy Miladi, Wemin namkaran ebeni dual moju defil alam, Rahanchuf in Lulmudun Sharkiye, Ze ist Tambulu, Halabul Kahira, Judith al Hayafiha, Mum canit kun afdal, minal mudungerbi, ze London uberis, alal akal bedikil Fatron Muduakan Mutisawi, Yani Anna Azdi, Oroba Makan and Tafawok Futri, U in Nu Ehna andametran Kaksbil Okul Wil Mawerit, Basilisar in Nufejjah, Khilel Karnuah Bas Kanfi Akbar Zilzel Terihil Veshery, Orob Batalat Alena Belat Bukhari, Udu Khan Masana, Sarhu Libatisema, Umantakutna Alam nel Islami can beishukud, zeik ennu ken bitfarajalakarteri, huhu bimru Demnapsura, W Ehnem Sharfin Lehau. Ashan Badikil Fatra, Nithul Fejwa Hadari, Nitfa Atamanha, Lelion, Bahil Halcominteri Hadar, Marh and Hotel Mubari Ratz Sathayel Metauddin in Nunismah. Benu Hadul Orobin Efkia, Umutafaqin Alenf Triyan, W Ehnash Op Kasule, Umustahid Laminash, Uhulil Haki, Ilimab Tamish Hubbis, Ehnabnan Hotel Hadartain, Tahtil Major. Ashan Nifham Kif Sarat Tower Til Matabah Sherikat, illih at head to the licbir benal hadn't. Keep it orba, u Kief Ehnat Akharn, Mab the Atawal Alekum Akhtar, Helun and Thulb Halkalatur. Ya Nilfellahl in Dizi Mathalan, Mekan Besh Haya Asam Nilfellahli Fiddelta, Belbilaks, At Takarir Terhiy, Mumkinit Ferjina Buduh, and Nufita Fawk Lilfellahli can Aish Biddelta. Minnahitil Emil Gida illmunach, hol elmuer canet Bomirons, Bitter Fikritul Merkezia, Illihi Itematul al Hadari. Filmarak is ilkbiri filam, illihi canet Uro Balgarbi, with Dowlil Uthmania, Wusseen, Can and Dhamkawimat Hadari Mutkaribakriven. Yanil Heraf Yedui canet Mu Judib Dimashku Halabul Kahara, can it bit metil, pummital at Kanil Veseri? Who can it turbut the jarti la alamitato of bad? Besisuali Lipitrahnefsu. Talama in Nulkul Khalina Niki Ken Muf and Naf's Katal Biday. Lesh Manthitna Dalat Mutamesiki, Bil Herafi Dawi, Ubkutsiitil Ard, Wu Orobba Idrat in Hatikzer Halkuud, Hasabhadaritna, Il Heraf Ishatar, Ken Yus Allah Dirjit Ibda, Bit Khali May Fakir, F in Nuibdel Majhud Besharitani, Bilmukabil Bilger Ken al Woda Mohtelf. Lennubuatemekanfiqimitel Herafiin, Zamanthutna. Fumumkin Oroba Buata Mesabatnal Khalifin, Mumkin Ashankunaj Hinjidvan, Una Jahnahad, Khalena Manfaker Psychlat Tani, Yaninomat al Hayal Adim, Il Ena Kunanajin Fiuktir, Khellena Manfaker Tatuiru, Bil Mukabil Oroba Ken and Meshakilikir, Mumkin Hil Hilat Hatusal, Le Thor Sanay, Le Nubil Adin Nas, Bed Dow Al Hulul, Ulala, Fahani Fam Hadakel Waatim Netteryh, Ilam can beish, psychirmutachabe, ilfellahamstatla, Ubilam al Isnami, il Muslim can Burbot Halob Mawkit Salah Illift had the chokolo metabo mataberta, Basmahur al Masana, Dharat Enna Ali, Muhumijindam, Illihi Sal Mikaniki, Fasar al Amilf Oroba, but has a bad day, Blaz Mikunmu Jud Awal Malmasnafta, We Rawlam Masna Biseka, Fahayatil Beni Adam Sarat Mit Mahwera, Hawadin the Wamu B shul, Fahonel in San Fakad Hurritut Tobi, Il canet Mortobitovishams Halina Nehki, Lasal Hel in Teji, Saril Muhammadish in Tep Tintaj, Yani Lautaban, Belaminnak, Matiji, Firak Elf, Will Mushmahil or Baumat had Howl in Medir Kazi, Wbail Marhalibn Belishnehki and Thor Senai, Illibelish at Sutha Bibretonia, Lemkanet Betaanim and Khatar, Ktirikvir, Willhi in Nul Heshap can be Hollis. Khazusanubseb, Towas of Pina is Sufon, with Tetvia, Fagabat in Giltraat, Kullas to Psikin Murab, Uhon a Belash el Bretonin, I Dora Almazar Taka Bedir. Fala Utah Trijlehom, Il Fahmil Hajj. Hella Ilfahmil Hajeri can mutwafer Biketra. Uh can erebin the Sata Umnil Moen El Bahari. Besfi and Dumushki Mumit. Let noat stihrajul meyh Jofi canet the fac almanagem Tabezu. Whuhonasarub Hajit, Madachat, Tish Fotalmai, Padarh Tra Il El Bukhari, Allah eid alem, Thomas in Yukman, Illibaden to warha James Wat. Fel El Bukhari Majetman Rafahri, let in Techanfi and the Kmushkili Bid Hal. Tobasin will alamel Islam, Shukan Watmel. Halseen can enter Makzunik Tirkbir Nil Fahmel Haji. Wusiniin can wear of kifis tahdumu mankurun. Basil Fahmel Hajeri can mujud bishamel dole. Ama Tamerkuzid Dowlif a sin can be Januob. Huna can at Muddinar Isir Tsadiyan wasin. Wuna il Fahim Bariyan can mukhiljuddin. Whalishi canili mishmujdihti Sadiyan. Amafalam nel Islami, Utahidan Fit Dwell Arabi, Mekanfi Anna, Fahim Hajeri, Alas Satah, Ili Bihali Amelita Tankib, Bustachlaso, Orhisa, Fatem that Mushtamaatna Alatari, Wilmoi, Will Adala Til Besharia with the Web. Fe Mekanishfi A Haf is in tom, B inhomi tiju bad I tija, who mumkin had the can altery it to help to Bam Thitna An Uruba. Ilihu Mekanish Ishmaqsud Daslam, letn'morad Mashtagratil Muharikat al Bukhari of Britania, I check at Enna Akbaru Akwa, Halkatijarie, Bitterhi Hil Besharimkin. Letnu inta and the Kahim Hajeri, Yatbarhis, Illi Adalasar al Hadid, Bkmiyatik Tirkwire, Wu Basarhisa, Wil Hadidilhis Wil Kawi, Bismehb Intaj, Alat Bukhari, Akbaru Akwa, Wil Elil Bukhari Mekanat Ratlahlanur, Bidun Munakh Kanuni, F Britonia, Wu Hadal Ed Demato, Isaural Majid, Sent Elfus Mio, Taminutin Miladi. Hey Thoura, Kayedat Sultatin Malek, W aset Mabda, Bra til Itira, Fasaril Mukhere, Mudrik Temaman, B innu Ayfikrahitla Fiha, Fi Ilo Aid Medimina, U Mahmib Kuwet al Kanun, Umafih Hakim Aunabil, Rahisterji, In Sadr Arbaho, Fahad Al Hafiz in Maddi, Helil Ihtra Atmin Ishimtakar and Dil Felazfe, Illihumi Kanubebuha Wahimin Huayat Miani, Lasana'a Biddur Melayin, Wilkul Bihawun, Ilo Hosab Hadasibak, Whella Turusil Amwal, Yeset Mirubil Muhterin, Ashani Kunu Shura Kamahum, Uterjalhum Arbah, Alan Kitman, Alam al Islami, Taht Hokmel Mamarikul Asmaniin, Kenbuatafi and Dak Merkezije, Khanaka, Will Al Dalak to Sadiya Sabili Canat But Morfi had Dowl Osmany, Bisaba in Tishar al Fasad ben Rusid Dowlib Hadak alwait, Hella Dowlit Faraj Alatharwil Mutarak me denitujar, be in no hadem shaqkum, ubella shatalla kawain, lam sodar tail amwel. Will Hajj Kanat Muchterifi. Fehekat tajer Sharki, Sari Habi Thurwitu, We Jemid Flusus Balkov Diniye, Aub Sebaik de Habi, Yitven Hatl Art, Bedel May Rahim Sikhali Flus, U istifmerha, Faryeb Domanat Wil Kawanin, Lehime Truusil Amwal, Can Owl Musmarib Nash, It Takad Musinaf Hail Mantha, Ufhi in Taanak Mwesitani, Ilgalin and Seminidam Tawafil Herafiin, Ilhizi Nakabet, Hayna Kabet canet Msitra Su, who can Ilha Ahdafikwaise, the inha canet but jarwa T al Khasara, with Saadum Fidait Meshirum, Bes Mushkilta R isi canet, in Hashadid Muhavada, In Hedaiman Bithowit Haved, Alatalidil Adime, Uptikroh Tagir, Fa'iatari Hashand Rayer Fihashekil in Tej Tabak, Canetwa Jahbirfit, Bil Mukabil Herb, Lega Dor in Nakabet Hei, Ufetah Hil Babla Rotz Mali Utenafushiris, Illikan endu Meshekil, Hnemnechkin Makanfium Meshekel, Bis Ehnna Amin Nakhil Asbe Litawart in the Domal Ghabi, Wal ishilisemahduhur Masana Iktirikbir, Wul Masana eliktirikbir hei, reyar chekil in tajwil adim, wendek fisharkni domitujara can ferdibintias, aufiu shharaket muakkadeyan, ubmujar dwa fetjir likbir, ferwit uptit esam, alalwarate, ukulwahab bin humaliban bim sikliflus, ubiftafiu business ilu, hal ishikan bimna mintarakum rasmeldahim, emelgerbiptacarun domin musihem al amme, ilisar shericket minhilelo, mabit mut ma motahba, auhi asam mebkun ilhasahibwahadien, let innuktir nasbutkunum Sherkifi, Ubheit Tarikal Mustatmin Batalukha Flusum, let in Nusar and Mishmutarat hot kulliflusek Bishiwahad bas. Fehai Sherikat sar and Hesuyuela Dahmi, Whal Ishiv tahadna, Bil Aswakal Arabia, Wfelkarnes Sabatosh, Mekanet Best Bidith Sauras Sanae, canfi enda Taura Elmi, befat alemat the Galilio and Newton, let in Nusaura Sana'i Halatilem Mishmujarte Amulet Fel Sefi, Biktubuha Elit al Khomasham Besit Fakarub Zekatum. La Ilelem sarmuhim juddan fesu, will Iptikarat Hai Sar Mumkin in Mahnis Tamilha, Bajal Intaj, Usarfi ende Kenadzi Jemey Malekyf London, Ilhibniar Nehki in Nucanet Owl Jisir Benel Elem, Wil Masana, Iliel Herfe, Toban Hadal Ishikan Mojud Ziman, Bas Khalil Nehki in Nujemay Malekiye, Abroza to Psikil Akbar Shwe, Utahidan Borob, Fasar to be a Juddan andchuf Usted ofizia, Ad Mahadad, U Wahad Bis Nasahat, Ashanit Badul of Kar, Will Alaml Islami Badmakanet Baghdad u Kurtuba, who were Rumsil Ibtikar Fadal Alam, Fahd Ibn Haytem will be runi, will Kawarizmi, Ithawa let in Mu asisat Talimi Likvire, La Inhatraqaz Alan Nakel, Wil Lugha, Utalhiz Kutu Bisself, El Hisha Glat Muhimmi, Bismachan Fisarifu Itimam, Alal Afkar iljdid, Wal Ishi Huli Adalem Fisal Elem and Su, which wishways are head of Talibbil Elem, who will wajah Ishtimae, Awil Monsibidimi, Mishtirah Adwat Bizid and Tajal Ard, Aubit Hassan Sanah in the siege methana. Lenu is a terja alhalkat al Khwarizmi, Lhi Alal Manasat So to Ybas, the Karnafi Hakif can fi mutotalabatra Isium in Su il amal, with Dowlinafsa, Alal Iktira Talafi al Kharizmi. Tidar Jaul Hara sibilkum link to Bahab description. Il Muhim in Nusarfian Fisalbin Herafi Ulim. Unatijat al ishi canet karifi. Khususan Lamalmantha Tabetna Bella Shetnebh in Nufi Hajjal El Bukhari, Walat Muakka detani, Ilhi Canat Mishaibaran etat Hadid Mumkin al Hadad Shatter Yamalakiyaha. Let in Tibdeqfihim Amir K Ladinimikal Harar, Wdahti Jawi Kawanin Temedu Delgaz. Issa Khususan Lamakunted Faraj al Hsumaqil Urubiin, Bin Humhawal Halat, Letharwe Hakakhi, Alat with Talelhum Deb, Utophan Sebnek and Nahda Elmiye, Bidum Menehki and Seb Nesher Hadal Elm. Fam Elf or Bami Uhams Hamsim Miledi, Ihtara Johan Gutenberg It Tabia, Illi Edda La Tabaat, Melein il Kutubul Manchurat, Utaban Hadel Ihtraqen Il Ramzi Muhammadin, Bin Nul Kutubin Toklet, Min Iden Rajalid Din Nubela, La Ammetisha, Ubil Mukabulul il Saf, Azar Sultan Atmani, Bayazid Tani, sent Elfurbami Uhem Sutamin Miledi, Faraman Bihar Metaba, Bilkhat al Arabi, U Sebab Hadelish in Nukan Haifin and Al Quranit Harf, Ufi Sebab Tani in Nukan Haifin y Tauris it in Nesahin, Tabanhada Kharar, Mishmehtaja Ulak Desh Ken Kari, let Nustamar letterat Kurun, who hell marrifibish bati or muklife, bilmukabil or robba canfiya and fijarma alumat, kutubiptuntabayaminushmal, u tobanil Furkat hey Jessadat, Lemanabilion Ghaza Maser, let in Nuhu F Aliyan Mehazamil Mamalik Bes, who ethbat in L Faju Saratik Tirikviri, Ijuush Batalat Barra and Chaja At al Muhatirinubas, Sarfia and Tandimu to Knology, Wasli Hamuta Tower, who had al Ishil Adrako Mamad Ali Basha, Ilistalamil Hukum Fosar Lebadin, B in Nullaw Bidubni Jesh Khui, Mabikafib in Nukun and Duslah Khui, Yishtarim al Urubiyin, Hu Elazimikunfia in Dubuny tahtiye, Bit Sanna Had al Islah, Wuhan al Basha Muhammad Ali, Atol Meshib of Karu, Urah Bena, Masana Nasij, U Maham al Sukkaru, Masabik Hadid, Wurah Ars al Bethet al Uruba, Ashantan or al Afkarl Hindisiu Tobiyim in Hunak, Ukulhai Kenat Muhawala, Ashani Siddil Farh Benubin Urububiin, Basil Mashwathim had Ken Behmil Juwa to Budurdaf, Al Aksil Mashru al Biritani, Illikan Mebna Al Mubadaratil Ferdi, Wraqsil Mal Hur, Himeit Il Mulki al Fikri, Letnumhamad Ali, Temed Alan Htikar Sarim, Sarat Hiddole, Ilib Tizra, Wutisna, Ubitajman. Fajama al Fellahin Wil Herafiin, Uh Allah Mishtuhb Masana Hakumi, Binidam Arablis Sukhra, Misharf Muhammad Ali Basha Kenukan Shuye Abli Shueyin, Letnulisarma Bizot, Hu enaf Silisar Biddaw Sovieti, B innun etalil Hafiz Shakhsi al Ibdawal Iptikar, Yanif Oroba, can endak amal bin Nakitkun Muhtara Methelan, Bittower Ali, Bitsir Feri, Bil Muqabilib Maser, Il Umel Aslan can Bikrail Elat, then Hakanit with Methelhom Sultat Dawl Kahri Alehum. Fabitali who can chai finul ali domarat hayat uslan, who had al ishilhella sinal masri metim de al hikim, aktarman ruusil amwel, ben Ruzil amwal, heel liphali fimashro mustadan, who foul hadl orbi in Taban, Wahsusan Biritania, Makan Bidhu Munafis, Bilmantaka, Lennu Hadel Munafis Law Sarkawi, Haisiter Alatari Tijaral al Hind, who I can at Binisbilhom Siv. Falin and Nehki bin Nutakalabit al Koal Kubra, Alal Dowlil of Manium Hamad Ali, Ufard Alehom, Mahadat Kasi, Zai Mahdit Leman, sent Elfutemen Mio, Temenutelati Miladi, U Badha, Tesweet London, F el Futeman Mio Arvein. Ili canatiyydar Bikadiye, Mish Besashani Hajj Mudor Jeshul Masri, Bel Bishurutalh Tasadiyfiha, Awel Hakanat and Humhumib Dhum Yilgu Nidamil Echtikar, Uiftah Husul Masri Udamil Bada al Orobiel Archisa, Mukara Nebil Bada al Masri, had ulitabkifil Ibda al Orobiye Archasanil Bda al Masriy, Fmaser Tehdian, La Ennubi Basat al Orobiyin Kenut Faukin Jiddan, Umasane Hum Canet Tintejib Kimiat Mahul. Fekansail al Urobiin bin Huminezdu Ser Admabidhum. Bil Mukhabil Masar Kenet Bit Belis Meshruha, Tabanhel Ishi Hal al Masana and Nash, Fmaser, Tinhar, Ulil Esaf Rijaat Maser Ladur, Il Atat Hayabritania Minil Awel, Binha Ebarham Mezerat Kotonikbir. Il head of Raisi Minhab in Hetmid Il Masana Elif Manchester. Utophan Mishmehtaj Akirak Shulisar Bad Hik, Il Fejwizadat, Hail Halka, Michel Had of Minha and Nunibia Atlal Modi. Basi Mamule Ashannifam Wakan Maser. Yani Ehnel Yom Fam Elfem Situ Ashrin, Wuliss al Fejwebin no Benel Garb, Zamehir, Umunkin Akbar, Echtisadya no Askarin, Felokanil Fahim will alat al Bukhari Hilibit Herikalam Belkarnet Tontash, Fedekalistina with data, homili behulkarne wahatulashirin. Wulmufarakab in no ehnadisatnabnafsil Makan Mintalakkurun, Dnin Bahir Bilmuntajini Hey, Wubnistah Dimob Sharah Tirikvir, Basbindalna Barra Gorf Tasnia, Umarakizal Abhat, It Dersal Ahmak Libnit Alamun Netaura Sana'iel Ula, and Nustira the Technologia, Mabisnalak Nahda, Bel Bisnaq Tabai, Yanifir Karnitis Atash, Hukamid Dual Fishark, Fakarul Maeshtaru, Kitaratu Banadak Min Uroba, Hekabiru Dual Hadith, Bil Mukabil al Haia and Nun Nahdawul Hadat, Tikmun bin Nu Intekun andakil Masna de Byamalakil Khataru il Bundukhi. Ulisatna Lilyom Nafsilishi, Nestawid Technologia Minbarro, Widdual Tabetna, Mab Chajal al Batil almi lepticar, U Mahada Arif of him, Shul ishilimkin Yikser Hai Sil Silimten Tehish. Basil Khalsa Minhail Halka and Nutafawkil Herbi, Mishhatmi Jugrafi, Ishi Mektub Alena Daiman, Mustahinna Tla Minnu. Lawekan Natijal Shajaf Tehadal Khararot, W Kesir Tahid, Ilimabdimkashla Udam, W in Naktidar Tibdi Muasat, Ibtihmil Ferd U Afkaru, Wil Faj will, he mishpsabnoqsatarwat, psychilwadah, mantakitnahiel egna al atlaq, wala inu ehnashub kasule, wuma and neptikar, ilmushkila siye bilmu assesat, il umamili mep tis tithmeribtahir okol abneha, hemeit ibdahom, meh ilhamustahbel, hadal ehnibinchuful yom, uli shufnazaman, will handal in chhufu, uheswulla. Lausilt lahon habinyashkurak, letin seta medina subscribe, like, alal YouTube, Ulobit Tabian, alamanasat sautia, medina folo, lausalkumishdinawalabel, w hadar al halkati lahat, wistanal halkati jutabona alamanasat tawasul ehtima, instagram wex, ulawa ajibkum towar podcast have been inu towar actor aktor, ishturkupil hidman metfu a la patrian link inatkulata description. Salamad,